Issue: Credit score graph is not true to life. Although figure is correct (cross check with Credit Karma). My score is close to 710 but shows only as 1/4 on the graph.
Details to reproduce: Check credit score on Monzo Plus OS: iOS 13 Device: iPhone 11 App Version: 3.41.1
Iām really surprised thereās not been any further mention of fixing this bug, seeing as it was reported on the day of Plus launching and has been acknowledged in the main threadā¦
I think this is likely to be the expected behaviour. The segments on the dial each reflects one credit score band returned to us by Transunion, which are uneven. For example the smallest segment has a 14 score range, and the largest is in the multiple hundreds
We make them even in size so that most people arenāt all bundled in one tiny section of the dial ( and you wonāt see if you move a few points), and so that when you improve your score and go up a score band you can really see that represented on your dial. Also, the vast majority of users are at the higher end of scores so using up half of the dial on lower scores that are basically never assigned is not a great use of space again
It sounds like we could make this clearer however, it might be a good candidate for a spot in the help section on the top right of the credit tracker page. Iām not sure Iāve elegantly explained this myself, but I felt you deserved and answer and I had one to give
What I am leaning on here is that close is a subjective word, and that sections in the middle are much smaller and so closely bundled together
They have (fairly) chosen not to share their score or screenshots, so itās hard to know for sure but this sounds entirely plausible to me
@Ronandocherty if you think what Iāve said doesnāt line up with what youāve experienced please feel free to DM me your score or a screenshot and I will double check
You can start to see from this why we went with the approach we did! Not that there is anything wrong with Credit Karmaās dial, but almost all of their customers will be in a small part of their dial and not see much movement when they improve their score
I agree that this is confusingā¦ Came to the community to report it as a bug and found this thread!
I honestly donāt mind the Credit Karma oneā¦ Well I find it a lot clearer. Monzoās looks much nicer aesthetically though.
Perhaps a dial isnāt the most appropriate way to display something which has uneven categories.
Iām also a little confused as credit karma seems to have four bands whilst monzo has five. Without any context anyway (is it actually five bandsā¦ Does the colour and description change with each segment?) itās somewhat meaningless anyway to me.
At the moment, looking at othersā graphs Vs my own it reads to me like I have to do a lot more good stuff to increase my score up one point when itās already highā¦ If that makes sense? Like itās harder to increase your score when itās already high? Because the gap is presented as the same size as a much bigger numerical gap lower down. Iām not sure if this is the case (I get the impression itās not) or if that description will even make sense to someone else, all I know is itās confusing. Especially when comparing my result to say, Revelsā above - it makes me think I have a long long way to go before I can improve to that standard, as itās a whole 1/5 of the possible score.
Similarly I found this confusing and came here to report a bug. Reading this thread has helped. Perhaps little indicators that show the value of each segment would help? Iāve no idea what the real values are so took guesses.