Debit or Credit Card?

We all know the benefits and pitfalls of using Credit Cards as opposed to Debit Cards. Which do you prefer and why and is paying by your Monzo Debit Card just as safe as if paying by credit card in your opinion?

2 Likes

If you had asked me this 12 months ago, you would have got a different answer from me.

At that time, I had grown out of love with credit cards and cba using them for a mere 0.25% cashback, so all my everyday spend went through my Monzo debit card.

The advantage of this, of course, is that you can see in-app exactly how much are spending, where, and how much you have left until next pay day.

Credit cards were reserved for purchases over £100.

Then came September. and Chase. All my spending under £100 reverted to them and Monzo card became defunct. In about 40 days, that cashback will cease and my spending card will change again.

Atm, I have not decided whether to just revert back to my Monzo card (the app is easier on the eye imo), or go back to AmEx for 0.5%, or my Barclaycard for 0.25%, or a combination of all my cards.

I think it will come down to whether I can be bothered trying to earn minuscule amounts in cashback. (My card spend is not great tbh)

Time will tell.

In answer to your closing question, I do not see why paying for everyday stuff by Monzo debit card should be any less safe than paying by credit card. And, tbh, though I use credit cards for £100+ transactions, I have never needed to use the s.75 protection that it offers. Conversely, thanks to a stubborn RyanAir policy during covid, I have made use of the chargeback scheme on my debit card.

3 Likes

Debit card for small purchases and credit card for anything over £20/£30 for rewards. Should really put all spending on credit card for rewards but it’s just easier to see in monzo what you have left in your budget if you use debit card. Have never had to use S75 or chargeback, but it’s like any insurance, you don’t think of it until you really need it.

2 Likes

I use credit card for all spending (aside from direct debits and foreign currency spending). I do this purely for rewards.

Using Monzo debit card instead of credit card does provide better spending tracking and forces you to only spend money that you have, but I can achieve an adequate (for me) level of spending tracking by connecting my credit card to an aggregator.

Yes for anything under £100.

But for purchases over £100 you can benefit from section 75 protection if you use credit card. Note you don’t need to pay the whole amount on credit card to benefit from this. You could just pay a small deposit on credit card and the balance on debit card and still benefit from section 75 protection on full amount.

3 Likes

I use the credit card for pretty much all spend and pay it off in full every month. My logic is that this way i keep cash in my account for longer (compared to spending that cash every day via debit card), which will help in some sort of emergency where cash and not credit is needed. Plus extra interest for all the extra days the cash stays in my account.

3 Likes

I use a Monzo virtual card for most of my spending. Big purchases go on my Amex or Flex for the sweet sweet S75.

2 Likes

This is what I do - I know I may be missing some cashback deals but I round up each purchase and save the change in a hidden ‘coin jar’ pot and enjoy the contents December 1st :slight_smile: It’s surprising how much you can save without ‘missing it’ by just rounding up and although I know its my money not the banks, I can often save much more this way than relying on some credit card cashback offers.

3 Likes

Debit. I don’t trust myself with lots of smaller purchases on a credit card, I’ll put on more than I can afford to pay off and then not pay it off in a month and start to gather interest. The points/cash back isn’t worth it for me.

Anything big goes on a credit card/Flex card though.

6 Likes

I buy it all on debit, for two reasons.

One self control, if I know I’ve the option to spend more I will (also why I don’t have an overdraft)

And two, for protection I’m happy with that afforded through warranties and 14 day return periods. So I’ve never, luckily, needed any more protection that that.

2 Likes

Solely credit card, unless it is not economical (gambling, csah-like transactions)

2 Likes

I reduced my Amex limit to the basic amount I can afford to fully pay off each month for this reason.

Now I spend almost exclusively on my Amex, but treat it like my debit card (so don’t spend more than I have in my account) for the airmiles.

1 Like

Does that not leave your utilisation % very high? I don’t think I could pay off my full limit with a year’s salary, even.

1 Like

What if you book a holiday or buy something big for house, is your limit big enough?

1 Like

I use a credit card for everything even though I don’t care about rewards and I know it causes me to overspend (slightly). I’m just very annoyed with all the holds merchants place on cards and the lack of instant refunds.

Really looking forward to the day when instant refunds are the default and I’ll move everything to my Monzo/Starling/Other Debit card as I think it’s generally a better experience.

2 Likes

If it’s higher than the limit I have (which it rarely is) then it goes on my partner’s Amex. In three years now it’s only once been required.

Amex also are happy to increase my limit should I temporarily need a higher amount that I know I can pay off right away.

If the money isn’t in my bank account I can’t afford it is my general rule.

As for utilisation, it’s always at 0%. The date that Amex speak to the credit agencies obviously is around my payday when I pay it off :man_shrugging:

2 Likes

Do you pay it off before a statement is generated? Otherwise it shouldn’t matter because they always report the statement balance

Generally yes. I don’t know how it works but it’s always showing at 0%.

It would show 0% utilisation if you paid off before the statement is generated. It will report your statement balance as your usage, regardless of how the dates fall

3 Likes

Just a note for those who say thankfully I’ve never had to use S75, it only takes once to realise how valuable that protection is. I have only used it once myself, and it got me nearly £200 in ferry tickets that I had cancelled within the provider’s stated cancellation period but which the provider refused to refund. You never know when you might need it!

5 Likes

I think Amex have reported non statement balances for me - as the date they reported to the CRA was nowhere near the statement date. As long as it was a cleared payment, my balance (whether it was due or not) would show on the x of the month. I since changed it.