Tap to Pay

Right now the only way to pay with your phone is via google wallet (or curve pay).

This is really unfortunate and highly monopolistic behaviour as google has decided that certain phones shouldn’t be able to run google wallet. This includes phones running Grapheneos (a cool security and privacy based project).

Currently, me and over 500,000 other users are looking for an alternative to google wallet on android.

I think it would be really cool if Monzo allowed you to pay with your Monzo card directly from the app.

Curve pay has a tap to pay feature and whilst it does work the experience is not as great and it is not amazing privacy wise.

I think Monzo would be able to implement a much better version of tap to pay.

I do not believe this to be that technically challenging to implement and in return Monzo would gain many users who have been looking for a good tap to pay alternative.

1 Like

I would bet good money the vast majority of users have no issue with Apple and Google Pay as it currently is.

The good news for you is that it is likely within the next few years the Apple/Google Pay function will be opened up by law - but I highly doubt Monzo will develop their own version unless it provides a good financial return.

1 Like

Its good to hear that theyll have to open it up but my point was that there is at least 400,000 thousand grapheneos users and there are many more who are looking to degoogle. There are forums dedicated to it lol.

Whether it is finacially in Monzos favour I’m not sure however seeing as most of whats needed for tap to pay already exists I imagine it wouldnt be to hard (or expensive) to add the feature.

A lot of people do use apple and google pay so what I am suggesting would be quite niche in the grand scheme of things.

That being said I imagine that not everyone in the degoogling community uses monzo yet and this is defintely something that could get people to use it, even if it is on the monzo paid plans.

Thanks for the reply though, this is ultimately still quite niche

Not sure Monzo is open to creating a wallet for a less secure operating system.

4 Likes

GrapheneOS is essentially a hardened version of Android, so calling it less secure is funny.

It’s more secure than the outdated Android OS versions that Monzo already supports for sure and probably more secure than newer Android versions, especially as it relies on several hardware components that are only available in some Google phones for additional security features.

The real problem here is Android for 98% of people is enough and I’m not sure Monzo wants to go after the 2% of which maybe 0.2% are Monzo customers.

5 Likes

It’s so secure banks don’t want to entertain it? :eyes:

It’s secure but there are a fraction of the users. It’s just a users issue. It is very secure.

The issue is attestation APIs (generally). Basically, GrapheneOS doesn’t pair Google Services, which means the Play Integrity API (or whatever the proper name for it is) where Google basically says “this phone is secure” won’t work on it.

Banks are too lazy to do proper attestation themselves and outsourced it to Google.

Does it have its own certified App Store?

It has its own App Store and recommends a third party app store called Accrescent which is probably about as secure as Google Play, which has about as good a security track record as I would if I shouted my PIN number loudly in the tube in front of 20 youths with balaclavas.

So easily targeted and vulnerable to attacks through weak security processes and protocols?

Sounds like it’s a good idea not to entertain other app stores or platforms then.

1 Like

Yes, Google Play is definitely all that. Monzo should stop supporting Google Play devices?

No offence, but I think you should do some reading about what is being talked about before you continue replying to this thread

1 Like

Well banks don’t really entertain operating systems really. They support ios and android (including grapheneos) because it makes sense for them to profit wise.

What I am suggesting is a feature that actually benefits Monzo and their users (if of course the cost of the feature is paid back by the amount of new users Monzo gets from it)

It is silly to question the security of grapheneos as it has been proven time and time again how robust it is.

I am glad Monzo hasn’t implemented anything silly such as some of the google play integrity checks and that is why I am with this bank because they are not as restrictive and do listen to their community.

By this logic they shouldny support play store which of course is silly. Accressant is an app store designed around privacy and security. It would make total sense for a bank to be on this app store of course that is up to them at the end of the day.

It does have an app store yes, and what do you mean certified? By google?

You’re saying graphene is secure and you’re promoting it like banks should be willing to make themselves susceptible to weaknesses to a weak third party who would no doubt wipe any liability of their product should anything happen to customers bank accounts.

You’re ignoring regulatory scrutiny put on banks to protect customers, and allowing them on to “weaker” platforms isn’t really keeping customers safe is it?

Except you are yet to mention how it is weaker in security when it is a hardened version of android?

Open your eyes before backfiring.

Banks already support grapheneos which is why your statement makes no sense. Banks also support very old versions of android which are incredibely insecure.

The feature proposed is not for third party operating system users it is for those people who want to degoogle and it would be amazing if monzo helped support that.

If they dont care about that portion of users that is ok but why are you so defensive of google?

Sorry?

Grapheneos is more secure than stock android and banks already support it. It is no different then supporting normal android except that stock android is generally less secure