šŸ“° Battle of the smartphone banks: Are app-only accounts worth having? - This Is Money

These app-only banks are like Marmite, most either love them or canā€™t think of anything worse.

Bit harsh :flushed:

They donā€™t actually give a verdict for some reason but this is a pretty good summary of the different challengers (+ Bā€™s :wink:) offerings.

Kind of crazy to see how much attention they give cheques..

Written by a true lover of Legacy Banking, clearly. :joy:

3 Likes

That Marmite analogy is pretty terrible.

Do people actively hate the idea of app only banks and recoil in disgust? In my experience, itā€™s only ever been a moderate ā€œwell, it sounds like an exciting idea but Iā€™m not sure itā€™s for me because Xā€ with a couple of people.

6 Likes

Not really.

I took B up on their Ā£250 bribe. Whilst with them I recieved a cheque (grrr) and used their cheque imaging to pay it in. It worked really well.

Iā€™ve since moved to NatWest (because Ā£125 bribe) and following the sale of my car have received two cheque refunds for pro-rats unused parking permit and vehicle excise licence. (Grrr). I had to find a bank branch to pay them in.

Overall itā€™s a fair article. Whether the marmite comment is accurate or not is irrelevant. Personally, I think itā€™s a silly comment. I neither love nor hate Monzo or Starling. Theyā€™re both interesting banks but they need to do better to challenge legacy banks.

4 Likes

Right so either their audience regard cheques as a key service - which as someone who hasnā€™t used a cheque in years, blows my mind - or theyā€™ve got the focus wrong & are putting people off the challengers for no real reason. Iā€™m guessing that they know they audience & itā€™s the former. So itā€™s a good thing that Monzo can process cheques :nauseated_face:

4 Likes

No. As youā€™ll know from my posts in this community, I donā€™t like cheques either. Theyā€™re an antiquated mechanism for moving money. In fact, I think largely the same of cash.

Unfortunately, cheques are still a thing. B handles this well, Monzo and Starling donā€™t ā€˜challengeā€™ this aspect for [reasons].

(Iā€™ve been unlucky enough to receive three cheques in three months. It was not frictionless. For many people, cheques are more prevalent.)

Just because the article doesnā€™t trumpet Monzo as the best thing since sliced bread doesnā€™t make it unreasonable. Well, apart from the marmite comment which was a little silly and inaccurate.

4 Likes

Please donā€™t - I didnā€™t say that. I wasnā€™t trying to imply it either.

1 Like

And nor did I say you said that.

Aside from that, I thought it was a fair article, useful for someone unfamiliar but not telling you, I or many in this community anything that we didnā€™t already know.

5 Likes

Letā€™s develop this thread a bit more shall we? :smirk:

I havenā€™t ever had a cheque book, and Iā€™m 27 :joy:

1 Like

whilst not denying some users still do receive cheques in payment - as an important way of receiving funds, and without a legacy current account have a certain degree of friction depositing them in ā€œchallengerā€ banks, looking over my legacy bank statements, I have deposited two cheques in the last 3 years but was given the option before receiving the cheques from the issuers of an electronic bank transfer , and Ive sent one cheque out in the last 3 years - my cheque book is in the house somewhere :slight_smile:

2 Likes

I still have the same cheque book form when I first opened my bank, the address on it is still for a branch that closed over 10 years ago. Iā€™ve written less than 10 in my life, but I receive many cheques each year. Iā€™m due another Ā£40+ one next month.

I get that theyā€™re legacy and annoying, but for existing older systems, itā€™s really easy to just leave that computer automatically printing cheques on the bottom of letters than pay thousands of Ā£ for a system overhaul to manage it all digitally.

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.