Youâve been listening to Martin Lewis again
Or best suited as what you want in the product with a competitive rate
I never listen to Martin Lewis, he makes me want to throw things at the TV
There is some confusion on this point.
As I understand it, an ISA account is treated as active or inactive.
An inactive account is one into which you havenât paid any money that would qualify as part of the current yearâs allowance. So a flexi ISA from a previous year will remain inactive if you only take out and replace flexi funds. If you manage to open an account without adding funds, that cash ISA is also technically inactive.
An active account is where you have added money that takes you into the current yearâs allowance.
You can technically add money to multiple cash isa accounts and indeed open lots of cash ISAs within the same year (though no idea why youâd want to!). You just have to make sure that you only go into your current yearâs allowance with one cash ISA.
You are not autosubscribed. The account is just inactive until payments in make it active.
What other features are you thinking of?
Nope, thatâs no goodâŚ
Of what other features are you thinking?
(Thatâs better)
On top of that, the key date is when you deposit money. Itâs irrelevant when you open the account and indeed what year is actually given.
Ease of opening and visibility in app. But we both know the arguments on both sides of the debate
Truth is, people who donât subscribe to forums such as this rarely, if ever, end up confused. Itâs only when we start poking around under the bonnet, that it all goes wonky.
(A straight lift from my book on ISAs)
Letâs lobby for an ISA dashboard.
I reckon the government could hash something together by 2030 at the earliest!
And then scrap ISAs 3 months later
Am I the only one thatâs disappointed that they expect ÂŁ500 to open it?
Shame Monzo arenât trying to encourage and include everyone into saving.
There are more savings options coming soon but the ISA was priority because of the end of the tax year
That still doesnât make any sense. ISAs at many other banks require only ÂŁ1 to open them.
And OakNorth normally is ÂŁ1000
Larger initial deposit means higher interest levels
It was probably imposed by the partner. I imagine as they offer more pot types there will be some without restrictions (maybe with lower interest). The other one was min ÂŁ1000. Would be nice to see more than one available at a time so we have a proper marketplace.
I do wish they imposed same day withdrawals on all partners though. I fear they have set a precedent now which means weâll see slow withdrawals forever now.
For savings banks (i.e. those that donât offer other products like current accounts and credit cards) a minimum balance requirement of ÂŁ100 or more, or some restrictive notice requirement, does not seem unusual.
See some of the top accounts listed here
https://m.moneyfacts.co.uk/isa/variable-rate-isa
The third party provider here (OakNorth) is one such bank.
All Iâm saying is if you look through that list that youâve provided, there are a lot with a higher interest rate (marginally, I admit) and only ÂŁ1 investment.
More initial investment definitely does not equal high interest.
Higher interest is normally only accompanied by stricter withdrawal rules.
My main point here is like a few other things that have crept their way into Monzo recently, this ISA launch doesnât seem very âMonzoâ-like. Iâm just disappointed they havenât stuck to their guns on being different, for the better.
So you think they should have held back the flexible isa until the ÂŁ1 savings account (possibly cash isa as well but canât check atm) was launched in a few weeks?
I think it makes more sense to release something that all your customers can use OR to release all of the offerings at once.
I cannot see the marketing or product sense behind releasing one of the more restrictive products first.
I would have also like to have seen a bit of innovation. There really isnât much separating Monzo from the crowd anymore.
I wouldnât say a lot. Only 3 out of the top 10 have a minimum balance requirement of less than ÂŁ100 and two of these accounts (the ones from Virgin) have withdrawal restrictions.
I agree that for high street banks (which I suppose is the reference point for most people) a minimum balance requirement over ÂŁ1 is unusual.
There was a lot of pressure to release ISAs and I think they made the right call to start getting products out. Later they will expand the offering but it may take some time and this makes them some money in the meantime.