Should Apple bring iMessage to Android?

General Chat Tech & Gaming
21

I’d like this. Main advantage iMessage has over WhatsApp is you can use it on multiple devices. The number of people I know with two WhatsApp for their work and personal phone is just annoying.

2 Likes
22

I trust Apple with my data over any other prominent tech company. In fact, I’d go as far as saying I think privacy is something that draws people to Apple (aside from the usual points around build quality, experience and all the rest of it).

9 Likes
23

I think one needs to differentiate between services that Apple needs to make money from, and services which exist to sell Apple’s hardware. I’d argue that iMessage is the latter type. It does Apple no good to make it cross-platform (and likely harms them financially), as much as it would make my life easier. Other services absolutely have to be cross-platform as they need to make money from the services themselves.

If Apple were to develop iMessage into some kind of payment network or e-commerce offering, then I could see it needing to be cross-platform, but otherwise I can’t see any upside for them.

1 Like
24

In an ideal world (for the consumer), Google and Apple would develop a universal technical standard based on the functionality of iMessage that would supersede SMS but for incompatible devices or devices out of data reach.

But there’s no commercial reason for them to do this unless they trade their users’ data to each other as part of the deal, or if they both decide to take on Facebook. The reason WhatsApp and Messenger hold the market isn’t to do with how good or bad these apps are, but simply because both have a large userbase, meaning people can find their friends on these services and will continue to use them while they are useful.

The dominant market share of Facebook is self preserving unless a significant portion of the userbase leave in droves or an enterprise with a combined userbase exceeding Facebook’s - Apple and Google together enter the market.

But Antitrust Law would probably step in and penalise Facebook and Google acting as a cartel to thwart competition, meaning the new technical standard would have to be open source.

So I can’t see a business case for it.

1 Like
25

I have no data to argue against this point, however a funny point that comes to mind is that a family member who worked for a large internet security company until a few weeks ago had his Macbook swapped for a Windows PC (HP, I think) as the Apple wasn’t capable of running security protocol to meet their standards.

26
27

What I’d love to see is iMessage for the web or part of iCloud.com
Same goes for Apple Music.

I suppose apples just stuck in a battle of whether giving people outside its ecosystem access to such services would impact or improve its hardware sales long term.

If I had to trust any organisation the most regarding privacy it would be Apple.

3 Likes
28

I’d love iMessage and Apple Music on iCloud.com plus maybe Health app and Home

2 Likes
29

I thought Apple had just joined in on the RCS talks?

edit: https://www.reddit.com/r/UniversalProfile/comments/ac7z28/reminder_apple_is_in_discussions_to_support_rcs/

1 Like
30

Because both iTunes and Apple Music are money-generating services, so there’s no real financial incentive for them to have iMessage available on Android.

2 Likes
31

This works very well, and uses Apple Music’s lesser known sign-in service so your account details are secure.

32

At least in the UK, would iMessage have any sort of impact if released on Android? WhatsApp is so firmly entrenched that it’s hard to see people switching en masse. What would be the benefit?

1 Like
33

For one-on-one convos I prefer iMessage over WhatsApp. It has a much cleaner look, I prefer how rich links are displayed, and I like the features better.

I use WhatsApp predominantly for group convos as it has features which iMessage lacks for groups i.e. the individual delivered/read receipts which for some reason iMessage omits from group convos.

Most of my friends have iPhones over Android devices however, so maybe if had more friends on Android I would use WhatsApp more as obviously the alternative would just be standard SMS.

1 Like
34

I just saw this today, and I think it sums up well why iOS users like iMessage so much:

4 Likes
35

In the US I agree the above is true but even when I was using an iPhone everyone wanted to message me, including other iPhone users, on WhatsApp. That’s where all my conversations live

1 Like