Post-Liquidity Event - IPO, Secondaries, buyouts... etc

Hello :wave:

As Monzo edges closer to a possible Liquidity event (IPO, secondaries, buyout, etc…) in the not too distant future, I’m creating an area for people to discuss what that means for Crowdfunding Investors.

Conscious this shouldn’t include actual advice due to everyone’s situation being different, but more to share information that will help people to make informed choices.

Discuss.

7 Likes

Post-Liquidity Event - IPO, Secondaries, buyouts… etc

Oh wow! That’s a useful post!

what that means for Crowdfunding Investors.

Oh, not for me :frowning:

Where are my friends who hold shares not from crowdfunding :cry:

2 Likes

Staff usually get a lock-up period after the IPO don’t they.

:eyes:

3 Likes

:wave: :wave: :wave:

4 Likes

Only have a few with crowdcube but watching :eyes:

1 Like

A popcorn moment for me, for sure. I only bought a couple of shares so don’t expect to be buying a new Porsche any time soon.

But very interested to see what might happen. It’s been a rocky few years for IPOs being highly valued and falling apart post flotation.

So be interesting to see what’s different here.

I can’t quite remember the context but I remember Tom saying years ago that if he saw staff rolling up to the office in Lamborghinis after an IPO he would not be impressed.

He did not say anything about living out a Star Wars fantasy by buying a Jetson One :smirk:

4 Likes

Those who invested the max they could, what sort of £ is that investment?

Just curious/nosey really

About £5k spread over the relevant rounds. £1k max in each of the first three rounds (2016-2017) and £2k max in the last round (2018).

Amazing to think the last round was 5 years ago now!

2 Likes

Madness! I remember the first round… clicked invest and the wave of people trying to invest crashed Crowdcube, no idea the investment was successful until a few hours later when it was confirmed by email

2 Likes

Yep, depends on seniority, round of investment, size of their position.

Fair play, that’s a decent amount and quite a while ago. I wish I knew about Monzo to invest but I wouldn’t have had the money (or balls) to invest that much so far out.

May you reap the rewards!

1 Like

Based on this comment;

and from what @chrisdalziel said, 3400 shares and £5k invested is £1.47 a share. I think I remember the last share price being mentioned at about £14. = £47k

So there should be tidy profit in there!

2 Likes

Actually not; IPOs are intentionally priced by the M&A bankers to “pop” (i.e. go up immediately) when they list. You can google that term “IPO pop”, or here’s Techcrunch saying the same:

IPOs are typically priced so that they go up about 15%-30% on the first day.

They can go down, but the people running the show work hard to price it so that doesn’t happen, and in the majority of cases it doesn’t.

1 Like

Yep, I think that’s right. By my count, the number of max shares is 3637.

Ok, so they go up for so some period, that’s agreed.

I don’t think that you can blanket say that the majority go down in the mid-term though without evidence. It would be easy enough to prove one way or the other; stock market data is a matter of public record. But it would take a fair bit of time and I don’t have enough spare to settle this debate! You got unlucky on some of those investments, but remember that the plural of anecdote is not data. I think we also need to exclude the SPAC frenzy, which I think anyone could see from a mile away (I certainly did!) was simply some regulatory arbitrage in a very heated market, and that the majority of those companies weren’t going to be good investments in the long-run.

I mean, those companies were all very much talked about in the media and rather hot companies - which probably contributed that that slump (IPO happens and then the fever pitch of media interest slumps over a few months, leading to reduced buying pressure and thus a lower price). But there are also a load of rather boring companies doing things like supplying sanitary supplies or engineering equipment and so on that also floated. And in aggregate I really doubt that they all tanked. But you’d need to pull all the data and process it to know for sure!

The article was just the first reputable source I found with a quick web search to show that “IPO pop” is a real term. Its age doesn’t really matter as M&A bankers are still dynamically pricing IPOs now as they were then in order to achieve that pop and thus garner positive media attention.

3 Likes

@N26throwaway is definitely right on this one! There was a brief moment where newly-IPO’d companies had a moment on the sun but that was really a symptom of the zero-rate environment and the furious desire for growth.

Renaissance have a US IPO ETF and it’s underperformed the wider market on almost every timeframe - https://etfs.renaissancecapital.com/us-ipo-etf#performance

2 Likes

Is this experience of tech IPO failures based on the last 2 years?

The valuations for Tech startups were grossly excessive due to too much capital chasing too few good investments, and the air has been coming out of the balloon for the last 2 years, so if you invested in IPOs since 2021 then you might as well have been taking your investment funds to Ladbrokes.

Over the long term IPOs have not slid in value soon after listing. They tend to perform in line with the rest of the market.

Year-end IPO returns in the U.S. 2005-2022 | Statista.

4 Likes

Given that many investors would want to exit we might fall foul of the IPO locked-in period.

Although this is mainly targeted towards majority investors from dumping their shares, just worried they might apply this to Crowdcube investors.

Also, if they list in the US that just adds FX risk and costs.