Can I keep shares if I close my Monzo account?

Hello,

Just wanted some reassurance on this matter - I have some Monzo shares which I will be keeping, but want to switch to another bank and close my Monzo current account.
I am assuming the shares are independent of having a monzo account, but wanted to check before I proceed.
Thanks for any advice you have.

Absolutely independent. The shares are yours, no one has the power to take them away from you.

3 Likes

Thanks. Thatā€™s what I thought, but appreciate a second opinion.

1 Like

The bigger question, where are you moving banks to?

1 Like

Most likely Santander for two reasons:

  1. Iā€™m moving away from using smartphones so need online banking, and they are offering good switching incentives (Ā£175 and a 7% savings account for 12months).
  2. Did look at Starling and First Direct as online banking alternatives, but they still require smartphone app authentication for security authorisations, whereas Santander do it via One Time Passcode text message.
8 Likes

If you are ok sharing, may I ask why? Iā€™ve often considered it in the past but nearly everything is moving towards needing a smartphone.

Iā€™m not even certain in a few years whether youā€™ll still be able to authenticate without one.

I do sorta get it and would like Monzo to actually have a fully working online banking experience at some point rather than an emergency web link with just basic stuff you can do.

However, you say your moving away from smartphones but you still require your phone for a code being Texted to you for verification from your new banking provider to access your account online. :face_with_monocle:

2 Likes

I donā€™t think Iā€™m that old, but even my OG 3310 could receive text messages :joy:

5 Likes

My first GSM phone was a Nokia 2110 on BT Cellnet (now O2) and that could send and receive SMS. Also the first Nokia to have that infamous ringtone!

3 Likes

Iā€™m interested in why the preference for a text message vs app authentication?

The HSBC/First Direct solution for instance does not require your app to have internet access for a security authorisation and I believe they still offer a physical security key if you donā€™t want to use an app at all

While Santander (with their old app) seemed to be moving to require the app rather than text to access online banking.

2 Likes

Banks will all be moving away from text for one time passwords as thereā€™s been so much fraud using them and the apps are much more secure.

3 Likes

SMS are less secure, and can be intercepted.

App authentication is more secure.

Santander is moving away from password authentication to app assisted authentication.

You likely will continue to need at the very least ā€œandroid goā€ smartphone to maintain secure access to online banks in general.

Note many banks used to support debit card + card reader. But those too are being phased out in favour of app assisted authentication.

I donā€™t think they are helpful to my well being, so just minimising usage as much as possible. There is a growing trend of people buying ā€˜dumbphonesā€™ as adults and youngsters are coming to similar conclusions.

On the authentication issue, banks may well be going that route, but I think regulators will need to keep an eye on this as it raises concerns about accessibility of service.

5 Likes

Yep, will be using old school phones or ā€˜dumbphonesā€™

Yes its weaker on security. But I wonder if now Apple will begin to support RCS messaging like Google/Android does (the industry agreed replacement for SMS which does have end-to-end encryption) that that would be sufficient for their security needs.

1 Like

My ancient Nokia 3610 could receive text messages back in 2001. You donā€™t need a smartphone for that.

1 Like

Sadly it doesnā€™t. Not by default anyway which is the version Apple are implementing.

And the SMS notification sound that used morse code: dot dot dot (S) dash dash (M) dot dot dot (S).

Many banks still have card readers or physical security devices, thatā€™s a way forward with it. I donā€™t think itā€™s fair to expect everyone to have a smartphone.