A better way to budget is here šŸŽÆ

Targets only clicked for me when I set it up to work on my free to spend amount. So excluding bills, regular payments, things I’d set aside in pots etc.

The one thing that would make it really eye popping for me would be to be able to have it off of my Left to Spend amount in the current account. That’d be epic.

4 Likes

Agreed, and I understand that’s what the Balance tab is supposed to be for to an extent, but it’s all a bit bare.

Give me the Balance graph with the info from Targets, along with being able to set targets per category and I’ll be happy.

What happend with Trends in summer 2022? :confused:
Until then, it had no problem to show individual Trends for separate Revolut currencies.

Now, it’s always referring to GBP Trends, regardless I’m trying to review my € or any other :pensive:

This is exactly my issue. January is car insurance month and the Mrs’ birthday. And that’s before I bought a new iPad i had no need for :man_shrugging:t4:.

5 Likes

Problem for me is that some of my bills/expenses I categorise as something I might categorise a daily spend as so I have to choose to either include it or not and not have target quite right.

2 Likes

That’s what I’m trying to use it for but those pesky extra payments to Flex or credit card mess it up.

So I track these as additional purchases (not in trends cos I don’t use Monzo) but in Lumio. But the same should work for target.

I have my target which lets say is £1000. But I also have car insurance which is £500. So I put the latter down as a different category.

It doesn’t affect my monthly target but I can still see that I spend more than that this month on a special purchase. I’ve still accounted for the money.

Visibility is key here, I think.

1 Like

I’ve just noticed my previous months numbers aren’t correct and it seems to be because not all the accounts are ticked and there doesn’t seem to be a way to update it, the checkboxs are greyed out? Previously I wasn’t including my joint account but now I want to (historically as well).

1 Like

That’s a sad reality of Monzo changing the app to store previous targets and the accounts they related to at the time… you can’t go back and reanalyze your targets in this way…

2 Likes

Yeah, I really like the fact they keep it over time - but I kinda want to go back and change some/all of my previous budgets.

1 Like

I preferred it when you could. I can’t measure if I’m improving like this :cry:

3 Likes

Yes, I too miss the flexibility… I’m no longer sure if it’s me that’s not using targets correctly, or if targets has a fundamental flaw… maybe I don’t really understand the problem it is seeking to solve… :exploding_head:

I think in the context of what Monzo (I think!) is aiming for with targets, having swipable graphs that go back months isn’t very useful. If I think about how summary works, you have the target for the month and then spending summary for the previous months.

Feels like that’s an easy fix for some users, me included.

Yeah, I guess I was just after a discretionary spend version of the spending tab (with a target ideally) but that’s not what they’re building. The way it worked before the locking of previous months was better for what I was going to use it for.

I’ve shelved the use of trends and balance until a better roll out of basic functions becomes apparent. The total lack of being able to adjust for 4 weekly pay / 28 day periods just makes the whole experience miserable

4 Likes

Is there anyway to just set a ā€˜Left to Spend’ calculation in Trends like the old summary version?

4 Likes

Alas no - at least not right now.

A few of us would love Targets - still a terrible name - to run off of that figure. But maybe Monzo has something else planned for it. Unless they’re killing the concept they’ll need to replace it somehow before they can retire Summary.

1 Like

sorry Ive tagged you but saves ā€œreplyingā€ to the last post which has nothing to do with my query

I can’t understand the logic you have used of ā€œneeding to spend Ā£620 a day to stay within targetā€ …and if I do ā€œyou’ll save Ā£11494.27 this monthā€ ??? with a Ā£10000 budget for the month …:man_shrugging:

Yay where do i find this £11494 savings ?

2 Likes

Agree with this. The writing around this could be much tighter and much better.

To take one example, ā€œyou need to spend X a day to stay withinā€¦ā€ totally sets the wrong expectation. You shouldn’t be aiming (or needing) to spend that. You should be looking to spend less than that amount.

Words matter and here they’re nudging you to spend rather than to come in under budget.

4 Likes

but what am I "saving"if I spend all my budget - compared to last year , last month , my average January spending over the lifetime of the account ??? :man_shrugging:

2 Likes