Telegram

Me too!

For no apparent reason…

27 posts were merged into an existing topic: Signal - Private Messaging

It’s encrypted by default, not end to end encrypted unless you use the secret chat option.

Seamless cloud sync/backups is a feature for lots of people.

2 Likes

At the risks of crossing the streams with the US election thread, saw this in the Grauniad just now:

Meanwhile, ex-members of the Parler service formed ad hoc groups on other platforms with lax or nonexistent moderation. On Telegram, a “Parler Lifeboat” group had over 15,000 members by Monday morning.

Oh joy

1 Like

Whilst I do trust Apple for the most part, if the data is encrypted with a current or former device passcode, it seems that the device passcode does not make up part of the encryption key as only one would work.

I would hazard a guess that Apple somehow have access and the key is only ‘granted’ once the other pieces of information pass some validation.

3 Likes

After reading that I think I’ll be moving towards home backups instead of iCloud ones.

I currently have all of my files in OneDrive (work, personal and photos). I’m not really sure how I feel about that now either as it’s not really encrypted in a private way. I mean if someone wanted to physically break into MS datacentre then sure the data would be safe but in literally any other situation…

2 Likes

Who is providing e2e encrypted cloud backup messaging?

I’m not that technical but I don’t see how iMessage and Telegram are that different. Both offer e2e encrypted messaging and both offer cloud backup where the provider holds the keys.

Maybe I’m a bit naïve but I don’t really ever think about the encryption side of things with these apps.

I don’t deem anything that I want to talk about to be that private that I must use a secure channel and really the most important thing for me is, what app is the person using that I want to talk to

1 Like

Maybe I’m naive but your attitude strike me as exactly how most people think about this!

3 Likes

I think so!

I use iMessage not because it’s encrypted or because Apple are good with privacy, but because it’s installed by default on my iPhone and it’s very easy to use to communicate with others who have an iPhone. If you get someones number, you know they can receive a text, if they have an iPhone it comes as iMessage.

I have Whatsapp for any group chat that involves people without iPhones, purely because it’s the most popular one. Not because I like the design or its features.

3 Likes

Financial and privacy benefits are two entirely different things though, it’s also considered more of a ballache to change banks than it is just to delete an app…

Another reason I’ve chose to leave, I turned down a business phone before so have all our business clients etc on my own phone, last thing I want is Facebook having access to the numbers…

I assume that’s client to server and vice versa? Still, if signal offer end to end as its default… It still has those extra brownie points?

hit the nail on the head :hammer:

Yes they are different. And if the internet has show us anything, it’s that people value (not spending) money over (their) privacy.

Defaults and interia are super hard to overcome. There’s a reason Google pays Apple billions of $ to be the default search in Safari, despite being by far the most dominant player and it being trivially easy to switch.

1 Like

And this is the key problem in my opinion, they should be at the same level of importance in tandem

Your privacy isn’t a currency and you shouldn’t ever be required to expend any of that in efforts to utilise an app…

FB have been ridiculously clever in leaving it a few years after the accquisition before doing this, if they did it back it 2014, more people would leave the service, but now Whatsapp has established itself in everyone’s phones.

FB know more people will just shrug it off because they are comfortable and whatsapp forms a central part of many people’s social ecosystems now

2 Likes

I’m not disagreeing with what you say. I’ve shifted a lot more towards the privacy end over time and have started considering alternatives to services I use (mainly Google).

But I still think people are coming at this from the wrong angle. When “normal” people are messaging, they probably care about what app their friends use and having their conversation history saved and backed up conveniently.

I pay for 2TB of iCloud storage which I share with my family because they’d all freak out if they lost their conversation history and none of them would pay for it themselves or connect their phone to a computer. Their phones are their computers.

Not to say that @N26throwaway is wrong but it’s just a different philosophy on security vs convenience.

1 Like

Oh no I 100%, it all boils down to what is more convenient and that’s why I say kudos to FB for leaving it until now to do it…

Hope you charge them interest! :rofl:

Wish I could double like this post. Thanks for the explanation!

I can see how Apple’s approach is superior but I think the main issue are:

  • you have to pay for storage for Messages in the Cloud (a hugh barrier to most people)
  • sounds like Messages in the Cloud downloads all messages to your device, which doesn’t sound great in terms of device free space

Ultimately I’m still hapy with iCloud backups as I trust Apple with my data but good to finally understand the differences.

3 Likes

I think this is fairly typical but it’s not a good thing.

It’s surprising how important message security is.

I’ve sent copies of my passport to friends when organising holidays, bank details to friends, etc so their is a financial risk if data is compromised.

And then you have the issue of embarrassing personal messages leaking. Ok, some people really have nothing to hide, but I bet the vast majority of us have been disparaging about someone in a text message, admitted to things that we wouldn’t want to be public, or otherwise written things that weren’t meant for sharing.

And the risk of blackmail? I reckon it’s higher than you might think. I could come up with motives for all sorts of things: Do you have access to confidential systems at work? Do you have voting rights or purchasing influence? Do you keep secrets that could help/harm other people? If someone could use your messages to blackmail you, there are actually many reasons why they might want to do this, even if you think your own life is unexciting.

So, while I agree that message security is low down the list of priorities for most people, I think it probably ought to be much higher.

2 Likes

I joined telegram and signal a few days ago. People keep popping up as joining telegram. Like the early days of Monzo. Also telegram sent this about 20 mins ago. I assume to everyone on it…!

2 Likes

We’ve used Telegram for a few years now, mostly as an in-house family messaging app, bc the children could log in on tablets (before they had mobiles). Being able to use it on most platforms is very useful.

Every so often waves of people join (I think a couple of years ago a discount voucher business started using it). I guess it’s very scalable, what with both groups and channels, which is useful for some.

I intermittently try Signal, last time (at least 2 years ago), it was a bit unreliable, but I suspect that’s improved.

And it has an actual iPad app! Something WhatsApp has been promising for years

1 Like