#TagYourTransactions


(Noel Edmonds Beard Sculptor ) #62

Maybe #Monzo is the new #Twittorz?


(Is Santa here yet?) #63

On iPhone you can tag it, search for it but it doesn’t link with others with the same tag by clicking on it


#64

#welovestarling (don’t actually have a starling account)


(Karim) #65

I m not sure what this update is about. Is it me or tags are not clickable, not highlighted in blue, no autocompleted based on existing tags, and absolutely not different from text I was already putting in notes? Seems to me the only change is that in the detail page it now says “Notes and #tags” instead of “Notes earlier” and in the notes fields there is this new text at the bottom saying one can use tags. I am puzzled! Am i missing something?


(CS) #66

Are the tags supposed to show up as blue clickable objects? It’s just text for me. Looks pretty pointless.


(Karim) #67

Yeah seems more like a “tip of the day” rather than “Introducing #tags


#68

Thanks, I’ll let the developers know


(Noel Edmonds Beard Sculptor ) #69

I have a #Starling account just for #Bants #lulz and #ApplePay


(Is Santa here yet?) #70

If you click on a feed item with the tag it should be a blue link


(Noel Edmonds Beard Sculptor ) #71

#FakeNews there is no #ApplePay


(Is Santa here yet?) #72

My tagz, my rulz


(Karim) #73

Oh now I see it. I swear I kept going back and forth tagging and untagging transaction and couldn’t see this at all!

Ok so it is clickable, and highlighted in blue, just not where one would expect it to be. A bit strange UI but at least it is working. Thanks


(JD) #74

I like the idea, as with others I’d love these as custom subcategories of some kind.

The ability to batch add/remove/edit tags and notes would be more useful to me. Maybe a way to go back through all my transactions with the note ‘Breakfast’ and change it to ‘#breakfast’ so it works with this feature?

I don’t mind putting in a little bit of effort and time to migrate all my info between evolving categorisation so long as Monzo gives me the tools to do so :grimacing:


(Stephen) #75

Like many others I’m not really getting the benefit of this feature. I’d rather the team spent their time on getting the bigger features out the door quicker.


(Gareth) #76

A quick visual explainer of the less explained:


(Noel Edmonds Beard Sculptor ) #77

#amidoinitrite


(Kenny Grant) #78

We know why Monzo hasn’t provided them.

That answer is from Feb 2016 and doesn’t really stand up to scrutiny, I’m not sure it’s worth looking at any more. The main points:

  1. If you use more than 1 tag per transaction (for example, a meal could be #lunch and #food) then we couldn’t give you easy comparison tools because the totals per tag wouldn’t add up.

They’re already plannng tagging things with two categories at once (expenses, holidays), so that part of the answer has been contradicted by Monzo themselves.

  1. If we let you create custom categories then we can’t aggregate transactions in a meaningful way. It would be much harder to send you reports and insights. We wouldn’t be able to tell you “hey, people similar to you are spending a 20% less on this category than you”

I do have some sympathy with this - it’s easier to work with data if it is consistent across customers (though the paucity of categories makes misclassification a real problem). To address that several people have suggested custom subcategories or allowing multiple tags.

I guess hashtags could work too, if they worked as categories do, not just text labels for search. Frustrating the lack of engagement with the community on this - Monzo simply isn’t listening to what people are asking for, instead slowly reinventing categories one piece at a time.

Since it appears this is Monzo’s answer to custom categories :scream:, please can we have automatic tagging based on previous classifications and include this in breakdown - very few people are going to go and tag all their data by hand on an ongoing basis. If that’s in the plans, it’d be nice to know.


(Kenny Grant) #79

The tag should autocreate a bullet point under the category, like a subsection. All displayed clearly on the spending tab

hmm, sort of like a subcategory :rofl:


#80

I suggested something similar to this on the “MONZO for Android - Release Notes (v1.25.0)” thread with a few pictures suggesting how it could be done: Monzo for Android - Release Notes (v1.25.0).

Also mentioned how the order of searching for tags matters, which it shouldn’t.


#81

Having to go back and add tags manually is especially frustating since clicking on the “Notes” section of a transaction resets a search back to the beginning every time, which has become incredibly annoying.

NB: mentioned in Point 3 here: Monzo for Android - Release Notes (v1.25.0)