Were for me, plus the name they gave
Another +1 that I wouldn’t use this feature as it stands because the page is veering on dark patterns.
I would ask the person for their bank details and do the transfer manually.
If I’m giving money to a friend that I feel might be up for Monzo, I’ll give them the spiel and show them the app separately.
If I’m just trying to give someone else money, I would use a feature like this. But only if it was completely painless and only did a potential upsell after the transfer was successfully complete.
I’m not even sure how many people you’d ensnare into signing up at the same time as receiving money using this tactic. Surely their prime requirement is to receive your money. If they like the sound of Monzo then they’ll sign up afterwards, personally I’d be rather scared of signing up for something and putting the money I’m getting from someone else into a thing I know nothing about yet.
Also: I never thought I’d have to use “ensnare” when referring to a Monzo feature. Very disappointed in this, and also very disappointed in the denials from Bruno and RobinB in the face of a fairly unanimous response from forum members.
Corollary: why don’t the monzo.me pages have a big button saying “Sign up for Monzo, top up your account, then pay your friend from there” as the primary call to action? Because it’s not the purpose of the feature - It would be a rude, delaying, confusing and slightly sleazy distraction. As the primary CTA is here.
When the recipient enters their bank account and sort code, these details are added to the transaction sender’s feed. Thinking about this from a privacy point of view: shouldn’t the recipient be made aware of this when they enter it?
It’s no different to me sending them money manually. This link is so they can input their bank details for me.
I flagged the same issue in another thread
My thoughts on this from the other thread
Interesting point. I’m not sure.
I’ve viewed this as no different to me sending a bank transfer where someone has texted me their details. It skips the texting part for them and they just tell my bank their details on my behalf.
I can see the argument that they might need making aware that I’ll see their details as part of the transaction. Whether the have to be told?
In that case, they’ve actively given you their details though.
I think this would solve it, for me. Nowhere in the current flow does it say that the recipient’s details will be saved by the sender.
I’d agree I think that would be a neat addition before the final confirm button.
I assume that the reason the details are saved is to allow for it to transfer as a Faster Payment? Could there be a mechanism to not share the details - but I figure that would mean there would be an intermediary processing step to do that? (I.e, I transfer the money to Monzo, Monzo transfers it to the end user).
Cool feature. Two buttons side by side would be my preference. One for sign up to Monzo the other for use other account. Both equal weighting. Fundamentally my friend just wants the money so let them decide.
After thinking about it I don’t think I’ll be using this in it’s current state. I’m likely to be using this for people I’m not particularly close with so having it so blatantly try to get them sign up to a bank when all I want to do is send them some cash puts me off. It’s kinda embarrassing.
I would prefer if it asked to signup after confirmation of money sent or if it prioritised simply entering their existing bank details with a less annoying ‘use Monzo add £10’ button.
Is it a dark pattern that when you tap an option on the initial screen, you can’t go back on the browser?
Be careful that you enter the right amount! Thankfully the app crashed before it tried to approve this:
OMG it is. That’s pretty naughty
This isn’t intentional! We should definitely have the option of going back before rolling this out. Unfortunately this is sometimes the kind of “unpolish” that lets us release really early to labs.
Not sure if this has been mentioned but an option to cancel a link would be useful. I have just created one to see how it works from a sender perspective but would prefer to cancel it off rather than wait the 7 days for it to expire.
You can kinda cancel it if you pop in your details, if you have the link still. But yeah a cancel button is a must.
I’m not even sure there’s much point in obscuring these links within Monzo, it doesn’t make it more secure. You should be able to see it again, and to cancel it. I’d also rather copy just the link, not blurb + link - I sent my first one to google by mistake by pasting it into a browser. These links will be sent in plaintext over insecure channels (email, sms), that’s the vulnerable point, when they are sitting on email servers and computers/phones unused.
I do think cancellation and showing the Monzo user the link is a must before this goes live. I’d also put a limit on it of say £1000. There should not be a way to send thousands using this method, it is too risky.
In future if this is widespread it’d be profitable to buy a browser plugin with an installed base and simply steal the money from pay links when they are clicked on, as all you need is the link, there is no second factor.
I’m glad to hear that. Thanks for the update