I know I wrote the questions, but I’m prevaricating on the last one.
I’d like useful, actionable insights (so more work on graphs!) but I’m not sure that we’re going to get something that I’d find useful so I wonder if the effort would be better spent elsewhere.
Arguably just categorising salary as income (taking it out of the spend graph) is worse as it will lead to just one massive hump for direct debits… Which was the reason that the pulse graph got nuked all those years ago.
It seems (to me at least) to be designed to capture spending (which is why income and savings are excluded). But if you do that without having a way to distinguish between committed and discretionary spend then you end up with a mess.
The solution to Trends (and to Pulse way back when) is, again in my view, to grapple with that as an issue.
For discretionary, something in-period (like Trends or Pulse) works well as a starter, especially if you could a) drill down (it looks like Trends is built for this), and b) overlay or compare periods (it strikes me that this might have been easier with Pulse).
For committed, what we really need, I think, is the ability to compare period-to-period, rather than within a period. For bonus points, come up with some generic bill types (mortgage, electric, gas , broadband, mobile…) and let me compare expenditure over time and across providers. For my love forever, advanced comparisons: what’s the month like vis the previous year, or the same month in previous years…
I pretty much only use it for my groceries category because it should have a pretty steady run rate and I can see what I’m spending on average a week. Everything else has too many peaks and troughs in the weekly view, monthly would be better for everything else for me.
I can’t say I find them particularly useful, just yet. I also really dislike the tap and hold with vibration. Maybe it’s just my phone but the vibration is really unsubtle😅. Also, I only knew from someone on here that tapping and holding did anything…
Back with Monzo after a “sabbatical” with another bank (it begins with an N)
Got to say, trends is really nice. It’s what drew me back tbh…so nice one.
Just adding my voice (may have been raised already)
Two things that would make this next level;
Combining budget and summary together (Ala RBS etc) - I personally found this really useful and handy to see budgeting.
Set custom date; for me personally until this happens trends isn’t really all that useful as it’ll be perpetually wrong cos I get paid quite early in the month, so it’ll miss out a fortnight of spends, and I’ll need to keep cross referencing budgets to see what I actually spent paycheck to pay check.
Just some thoughts, nice job Monzo on this one, looks slick