Doctor Who Season 11


(Liam) #81

And rightly so, this is a Doctor Who thread! If ever there was a place for pedentry. :stuck_out_tongue:


(Simon B) #82

You mean pedantry… But I’m thinking you did that on purpose :joy:


(Tony Hoyle) #83

I like most of the stylistic changes… I just wish chibnall would learn to write endings…

A ‘race’ where nobody races and the last 2 minutes we get ‘let’s call it a draw then’
Spider invasion… ends with ‘and then they all died. the end. Oh and guns are bad, mmkay’

I missed the last episode but actually been advised not to bother, which is going some, considering I sat through the whole of The Gunfighters without punching anything… I’ll probably watch it tomorrow morning so I stay in sequence.

OTOH next week is a guest writer, so maybe the combination of chibnalls direction and another writer is the sweet spot.


(Nick) #84

I saw that as a nod to War of the Worlds (and an unexpected demonstration of the square-cube law actually being applied!).


(Liam) #85

If only… :face_with_hand_over_mouth:

@TonyHoyle: the worst thing about the guns-bad stuff in Arachnids (something which I can totally get behind) is that in that case it really seemed like shooting the fucker was the kindest thing to do for it. It was suffering a slow painful death. :disappointed_relieved:


(Tony Hoyle) #86

And it would have probably been better writing to point out the moral ambiguity there… eg. if the doctor had talked nottrump into handing her the gun then she immediately turns around and shoots the spider anyway, because it was the right thing to do.

Or any kind of ending at all that didn’t mean sheffield was still infested with mutant spiders and all the ones in the hotel were going to die a slow death trapped in a room.


(Tony Hoyle) #87

And… it was. That was easily the best episode of the series so far.

Now can some confiscate chibnall’s writing implements so we can keep the quailty up? :stuck_out_tongue:


(Liam) #88

One of the best maybe (Pting! :smirk:).

Honestly I was ready to declare tonight’s just awful until the twist. After that it was great.


(Richard Cook) #89

5 posts were split to a new topic: Removed Posts - 12/11/18


(Richard Cook) #90

Hey all, just removed a few posts that were getting this thread off-topic.

Feel free to discuss the new series of Doctor Who - including what you like and don’t like. But, as always, let’s keep it inclusive.

(And thanks for flagging posts).


(Simon B) #91

Brilliant episode last night for sure. Although, slightly more focus on Britain’s culpability of partition would have been nice. If you weren’t aware of history you might have seen it as something that just happened.


#92

I always find historical and political ones to be the better episodes.

It started as that from a sci fi perspective, and people who think otherwise aren’t aware of it’s whole history.


#93

Can’t you soft delete posts, or at least move them to a different thread without leaving a redirect? It’s very jarring.